Hotels in Shelter Island

Shelter Island is the secret getaway you didn’t know you needed, perched between the Hamptons and the North Fork with a laid-back, barefoot-chic vibe that makes every stay feel like your own private escape. Think historic inns with porch swings, breezy boutique hotels perfect for couples on a romantic jaunt, and family-friendly resorts where the kids can roam free. Whether you’re chasing sunset cocktails by the water or just want to wake up to birdsong and briny sea air, Shelter Island’s hotels have the charm and character to match every mood - just bring your swimsuit and a sense of adventure.